En EspaŅol

Q. Who is Mr. Smarty Plants?

A: There are those who suspect Wildflower Center volunteers are the culpable and capable culprits. Yet, others think staff members play some, albeit small, role. You can torture us with your plant questions, but we will never reveal the Green Guru's secret identity.

Help us grow by giving to the Plant Database Fund or by becoming a member

Did you know you can access the Native Plant Information Network with your web-enabled smartphone?

Share

Ask Mr. Smarty Plants

Ask Mr. Smarty Plants is a free service provided by the staff and volunteers at the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center.

Search Smarty Plants
    
 
See a list of all Smarty Plants questions
Can't find the answer in our existing FAQs, submit a question to Mr. Smarty Plants.
Need help with plant identification, visit the plant identification page.
 
rate this answer
1 rating

Thursday - January 27, 2011

From: Hutto, TX
Region: Southwest
Topic: Non-Natives, Compost and Mulch, Transplants, Trees
Title: Problems with Texas Ash and non-native Bradford Pear in Hutto TX
Answered by: Barbara Medford

QUESTION:

We have planted two trees in our back yard. The first one(a Bradford Pear) died and the second one (a Texas ash) doesn't look like it's doing very well. Our back yard is mostly black clay about 1 foot down. What kind of tree can I plant back there? or should I just give up on getting any shade from the sun? Thank you,

ANSWER:

The clay in your soil certainly doesn't help a lot, but everywhere around you no doubt has the same clay soil, and still trees grow and flourish. About the best we can do is ask you some questions (don't send us the answers) to help determine why these trees have not done well and make some recommendations for the next trees you plant.

To begin with, the Bradford Pear is a selection of Pyrus calleryana, native to Korea and China. The selection called the Bradford Pear was released into the retail market in 1963, with a lot of attention. However, as the trees first planted have begun to mature, a number of problems have appeared, the main one being weak trunks and branches, very susceptible to storm damage. Since this tree is not native to North America and certainly not to Texas, we would not recommend replanting under any circumstances. A tree native to an area always has a higher likelihood of being well-adapted to the soil, rainfall and climate conditions. This article from Floridata will give you more information.

Which brings us to Fraxinus texensis (Texas ash). This tree is native to Texas, although it likes a slightly acidic soil, which you probably don't have in Williamson County. However, this USDA Plant Profile map for Texas Ash shows it as being native in your area, so perhaps that is not a big factor. Here is a note from the Growing Conditions on our webpage on this plant:

"Soil Description: Rocky soils. Limestone-based, Sandy, Sandy Loam, Medium Loam, Clay Loam, Clay, Caliche type
Conditions Comments: Texas ash is a small tree with an attractive, densely branched canopy. Pinnate leaves have brilliant fall color. Long-lived and healthy. Very drought-tolerant. Low water requirements."

This brings us to another possibility for the problems both trees have had: planting practices. In Texas, trees should be planted in late Fall or Winter, when the tree is semi-dormant, and the sun will not burn the little new tree. We found a very complete set of instructions on planting a tree from TreeHelp.com A Step by Step Guide to Planting a Tree. The only thing we disagree with is putting peat moss into the dirt mix, we prefer a good compost. Note especially their recommendations on how to deal with a clay soil so the sides of the hole don't "glaze." Watering should be done by sticking a hose down into the soil and letting it dribble slowly until water appears on the surface of the soil. A thorough watering once a week is better than depending on sprinkler systems or rain. Of course, if there has been a lot of rain recently, don't water.

Drainage is very important for all tree roots, they cannot thrive in a clay soil that does not drain. The addition of compost will greatly aid in helping the little rootlets access the nutrients in the soil, as well as improving drainage. Mulching over the roots is also a good idea to protect from extreme heat and cold, but do not pile it up next to the trunk, as that could be a shelter for insects and fungi harmful to the tree.

Since we have no idea exactly what could have caused you the problem you have described, we can only suggest that if you plant more trees, you plant those native to your area, plant them in the cool weather, and water gently. Here are some trees native to Central Texas that could be good selections; follow each plant link to each webpage and read the expected size, light and moisture requirements, and description to determine if that is the right tree for you.To make your own list, go to our Recommended Species section, click on Central Texas on the map, and select for "trees" under Habit or General Appearance.

Cercis canadensis var. texensis (Texas redbud)

Chilopsis linearis (Desert willow)

Quercus macrocarpa (Bur oak)

Taxodium distichum (Bald cypress)

From our Native mage Gallery:


Cercis canadensis var. texensis


Chilopsis linearis


Quercus macrocarpa


Taxodium distichum

 

 

More Compost and Mulch Questions

Native landscaping in Austin
August 24, 2009 - I am planning to convert a pretty large portion (app. 500 sq feet) of my front yard from St. Augustine to an area with native and well-adapted plants. I have solarized the area to kill off grass and ...
view the full question and answer

Native Grass is Falling Over
November 09, 2011 - Hi Mr. Smarty Plants, I've tried to find this answer but am stumped as to the cause. We live in Fredericksburg, TX and have several different tall grasses, Yellow Indian grass, Little Bluestem, wire...
view the full question and answer

Erosion control on partially shaded slope
November 27, 2010 - Mr. Smarty Plants, I live in Atlanta, GA. My house is on a hill, and I am beginning to have erosion at my backyard porch (concrete slab, on the corners especially). The soil is mainly red clay, a...
view the full question and answer

Problems with Eastern hemlock in Greenville SC
July 02, 2009 - Dear Mr. Smarty Plants, I have a beautiful, young, 5 and a half foot tall Eastern Hemlock. I purchased and planted it two years ago in the fall. It has been doing very well all this spring. And ne...
view the full question and answer

Will wood shavings in the soil require nitrogen from Charleston MO
May 04, 2011 - I cut down a big maple tree and a lot of the wood shavings was left in the soil. I planted a flower bed over the area this spring. I later read that the wood chips in the soil would use a lot of nitro...
view the full question and answer

Smarty Plants's Facebook profile Support the Wildflower Center by Donating Online or Becoming a Member today.

Mr. Smarty Plants wants you to be his Facebook friend. Click the Facebook icon to add yourself to Mr. Smarty Plants list of friends.
E-NEWSLETTER | BECOME A MEMBER | DONATE NOW | MEDIA | SITEMAP | STAFF
© 2015 Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center