Native Plants

Q. Who is Mr. Smarty Plants?
A: There are those who suspect Wildflower Center volunteers are the culpable and capable culprits. Yet, others think staff members play some, albeit small, role. You can torture us with your plant questions, but we will never reveal the Green Guru's secret identity.
Did you know you can access the Native Plant Information Network with your web-enabled smartphone?
Ask Mr. Smarty Plants is a free service provided by the staff and volunteers at the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center.

rate this answer

Monday - March 26, 2012
From: Austin, TX
Region: Southwest
Topic: Diseases and Disorders, Trees
Title: Hypoxylon Canker removal in Austin TX
Answered by: Brigid & Larry Larson
QUESTION:
I have several oaks that appear to have been killed by Hypoxylon atropunctatum from last summer's drought. Is it safe to cut them down in March or does that risk spreading Oak Wilt too. Should I let them sit there dead until summer?ANSWER:
Mr Smarty Plants offers his condolences on the loss of your Oaks. That always hurts.
Your question evoked considerable discussion amongst the experts at the Ladybird Johnson Willdflower Center. It's clear the trees need to be removed, but there were good arguments for either "right now" or "wait until next winter". A general concensus clearly recommended that you employ the services of a Texas Oak Wilt Certified Arborist and get a expert diagnosis of the trees condition and recommendation for how to go on.
The argument for waiting is the one you implied. When considering Oak Wilt, it’s just a bit late to be cutting trees down. The standing advice is to prune from December into early February. The risk you induce by waiting is that the Hypoxylon Canker that is there may infect other trees. You can have hope that this year this risk is minimal as the references linked below imply that healthy, well watered trees are not all that susceptable to the canker. There is also a risk, in truly advanced cases, that the tree wood will be weaked by the fungus and drop limbs or fall.
The argument for "cutting now" is that you do have Hypoxylon Canker there. Leaving the trees stand until summer or later is leaving a viable source of the fungal infection in place. The Florida Forest Service describes the fungal growth process. In the spring or early summer, masses of spores called conidia are produced on the surface. Later in the summer or fall, after the powdery conidia are gone, the fungal stromata thicken and produce another type of spores. These are the infective ascospores which are present later in the summer or fall. The Florida Forest Service recommends removal of the tree.
The Oklahoma State Extension recommended “In a home setting, individual trees that have more than 15% of the crown area infected should be cut to ground level and burned. No stump should be left because stroma development has been observed even on very small stumps.” The Texas Forest Service also has a publication describing the course of the infection, and there are several publications from TAMU including a 3-part fact-sheet. This one addresses managing Hypoxylon canker.
It makes sense to remove trees that can serve as viable sources of continuing infection, but at the same time one should be concerned about Oak Wilt as that is a continuing concern for the other trees. One should take extreme care that the neighboring Oak trees are not damaged by the removal and follow the expected precautions following the work. This includes tool cleaning, not storing infected wood on the property, and all pruning cuts or other wounds, including freshly-cut stumps and damaged surface roots, should be treated immediately with a wound or latex paint to prevent exposure to contaminated insect vectors. I will repeat the recommendation of consulting a certified Oak Wilt Arborist!
Mr Smarty Plants has produced several answers concerning Hypoxylon Canker, most of them involve determining that this is the source of illness. There are several other good links in these answers though.
More Diseases and Disorders Questions
Beneficial earthworms attacked by fire ants
August 04, 2006 - Is there a right way or a trick to releasing earthworms? I have a friend who has an abundance of earthworms in their soil so I took advantage of the situation. I released them in my freshly tilled gar...
view the full question and answer
Tan, rough, fan-shaped growth on mountain laurels
July 01, 2014 - A tan rough fan-shaped "something" is growing at the end of the mountain laurel branch where the flowers would be .. what is it and can it harm the plant?
view the full question and answer
American beautyberry losing leaves in San Antonio
August 03, 2015 - I planted 3 American beautyberry last fall, and 2 of them are doing great. All the leaves on the 3rd one suddenly started dropping about 2 weeks ago and it looks dead. I can't find anything to tell...
view the full question and answer
Effect of heavy rains on Lindheimer Muhly
May 04, 2015 - It is April 2015, in San Antonio we've had very heavy rains recently. My Lindheimer muhly, which was looking beautiful, has now turned brown all over. Is this normal or is this a problem?
view the full question and answer
Fasciated Texas mountain laurel
November 05, 2013 - I've noticed some strange things hanging off some of the purple mountain laurels in my area. They hang low, and look almost like large, dangling trumpet flowers, but are flat, and have little bumps o...
view the full question and answer
Support the Wildflower Center by Donating Online or Becoming a Member today. |