This is a follow up to an earlier question, posted Sept 20, about Viburnum dentatum shrubs. I'm not sure I understand your answer. If the person having trouble getting berries went out and bought a Viburnum dentatum from an entirely different nursery several year later, and planted it nearby would they have a chance of avoiding the clone problem? (I have to admit the first question came from me, too!) The first time around I bought five of the cultivar "Blue Muffin." TThis time I'm thinking I should go to a small native plant nursery and look for one that isn't a cultivar. I have more space for another shrub right next to the hedgerow. Would that work? I want the berries because I want to feed birds. Thanks so much for the help.
In reference to your first question, it does sound like you have a self-incompatibility problem since all your plants were bought at the same time and were the same "Blue Muffin" cultivar. Many plants exhibit self-incompatibility—a genetic trait produced by a gene that creates a chemical barrier when the pollen of a genetically identical plant falls on the carpel (female part). This chemical barrier prohibits the pollen from fertilizing the ovules and there will be no fruit. V. dentatum plants are commonly propagated vegetatively from cuttings. If they are propagated from the same stock, such as your cultivar "Blue Muffin" must have been, they are going to be genetically identical—in other words, clones. So, you do need at least one plant that isn't a clone of your "Blue Muffin" plants to produce pollen that won't be chemically barred from fertilizing your flowers. The University of Connecticut site lists 8 cultivars of V. dentatum, including your "Blue Muffin", so there are other possibilities. I recommend that you visit our National Suppliers Directory and enter your city to find nurseries in your area that specialize in native plants. You can visit their websites (if they list one) and/or telephone them to find out what cultivars they carry of V. dentatum. Just to be on the safe side you might buy two completely different cultivars to plant.
More Propagation Questions
Propagation of native Ohio buckeye from seed September 25, 2008 - My granddaughter has collected "buck eyes"; can we plant them to start our own tree? If so, how do we go about it!
view the full question and answer
Can trees survive if trunks are buried under 3-5 ft of soil? January 27, 2012 - We have two cedar elms and a mesquite that I protected from backfill as our Texas Hill Country lot was leveled in preparation for building a house. The bulkheads are now holding back 3' to 5' of ma... view the full question and answer
Transplanting wild sumac September 23, 2010 - About a month ago I dug up five sumac from my backyard in Aylmer Quebec. I potted them. They now look dead. I wanted to transplant them at my cottage in Barrie Ontario. Can I still transplant them... view the full question and answer
Propagation of Prunus Mexicana in Rusk TX July 29, 2009 - How do you scarify seeds from the Prunus Mexicana?
Can the branches be made to grow roots? view the full question and answer
Age before blooming of a Fendler rupicola from Elmendorf TX April 06, 2014 - How old does a Fendlera rupicola plant have to be before it will bloom? view the full question and answer