From:Chicago, IL Region: Midwest Topic: Invasive Plants Title: Getting rid of Polygonum punctatum (dotted smartweed) Answered by: Nan Hampton
Dear Mr. Smarty Plants,
After much online research, my property has been invaded by what I believe to be Persicaria polygonum punctata, more commonly known as dotted smartweed. I have tried horticultural vinegar but it only curled the leaves. Additionally, I have read that horticultural vinegar detrimentally changes the soil.
These plants become at least three feet tall so it's hard to spray all parts of it. I have thought of covering them with clear plastic sheeting but don't know if that is enough heat to kill the roots. I feel my last resort is glyphosate, of which I have heard pros and cons. Digging them out is as horrendous as trying to comb out knotted hair and I do not have the time nor energy as they are everywhere.
As I have said, I have been all over the Web looking for an answer as to how to kill these plants. Do you have any suggestions? I would really appreciate any advice you can provide.
I assume you mean Polygonum punctatum var. punctatum (syn.=Persicaria punctata)(dotted smartweed), a plant native to North America. Another common name is water smartweed. Or, are you talking about Polygonum persicaria (spotted ladysthumb). This is an introduced species. Whichever one it is, the treatment will be the same. The most environmental friendly way, of course, would be to dig them out or pull them up. Alternatively, instead of spraying them you can cut them off near the ground and carefully paint or inject the cut stalk with herbicide. This would put the herbicide where it would do the most good and would be the least harmful to other plants and to the environment. If you spray them, you run the risk of harming other plants nearby that you want to save. Consult with the Cook County Extension Service or visit a reputable garden nursery for advice on the best herbicide to use. Please read carefully all instructions that come with the chemical and follow the safety guidelines to protect yourself and the environment.
More Invasive Plants Questions
Landscaping a new yard in El Paso, TX July 01, 2010 - I am starting my back yard, we want to plant some sod grass and shade trees. We were doing some research and came across the Paulownia and the Royal Empress tree. I like them since they grow very fast... view the full question and answer
Removal of trumpet creeper in Elkview MI April 09, 2010 - Thank you for your informative response about the trumpet creeper. As pretty as it is- it will have to go! Trees are more important.
view the full question and answer
Need suggestions for replacing invasive privet in the Dallas area. April 20, 2011 - We are removing invasive privet at a project. We will need to substitute native plants and would like to know how to find out which plants should be used. We are in the Dallas area. Thank you. view the full question and answer
Dandelions in bluebonnets in Bastrop TX May 31, 2012 - I have a 20'x60' front yard area where I planted bluebonnets. It has become horrifically inundated with dandelions.
How do I eradicate the dandelions while preserving the bluebonnets ?
Thanks ... view the full question and answer
Bald cypress causing problems in Spring TX June 22, 2010 - There is a 50+ ft Bald Cypress growing near my property line. While the tree has grown substantial knees along the driveway and some as far as 35 ft from the tree in my flower beds, I do not see any d... view the full question and answer